Mr. Pumpkinhead Posted June 1, 2011 Share Posted June 1, 2011 Okay... assuming you could kill off one character from HP that survived in place of one that died, which good natured character would you kill off and which one would you save. Then which evil or bad natured character would you kill off and which one would you save? i.e. I would have saved Tonks (so Teddy wouldn't grow up without both his parents) and killed off George so one twin didn't have to live without the other. The killing off part is a lot harder than I thought it would be. Gives me a small sense for how difficult it must have been for JKR to kill off her own characters. Bad guys I'd have saved Peter Petigrew, I think his betrayl deserved a long stay in Azkaban like Sirius had to suffer. I'd have killed off Lucious Malfoy... no way he deserved to live IMO even though like all pawns for Voldemort a lot of his loyalty was fear... he also had horribly misguided views about Muggles and "Mudbloods". Link to post Share on other sites
padfoot Posted June 1, 2011 Share Posted June 1, 2011 The killing off part is a lot harder than I thought it would be. Gives me a small sense for how difficult it must have been for JKR to kill off her own characters. True. Never thought about this! Must be challenging. I would save Fred, in replacement for... fooor... Cornelius Fudge. I'd save Hedwig instead of Scabbers. Anddd Sirius or Dumbledore or Snape (or Tonks or Lupin or Dobby or...) Does Umbridge count to replace one of them? Suppose she's more bad than good. Link to post Share on other sites
Mrs Duck Posted June 1, 2011 Share Posted June 1, 2011 I would have saved Fred to kill Neville, that's all I can think of Link to post Share on other sites
Mr. Pumpkinhead Posted June 1, 2011 Author Share Posted June 1, 2011 I would have saved Fred to kill Neville, that's all I can think of You don't have to take so much delight in it! j/k Link to post Share on other sites
Mouse Rat Posted June 1, 2011 Share Posted June 1, 2011 I must agree with Jon. Save Tonks,kill George. Her death upset me the most for some reason... And the reason for my choices have already been elaborated by the mentioned mister Jon. Link to post Share on other sites
Babba O'riley Posted June 1, 2011 Share Posted June 1, 2011 save fred, kill mcgonagal...would be interesting Link to post Share on other sites
Slash Posted June 2, 2011 Share Posted June 2, 2011 True. Never thought about this! Must be challenging. I would save Fred, in replacement for... fooor... Cornelius Fudge. Does Umbridge count to replace one of them? Suppose she's more bad than good. agreed, i'd trade off Umbrigde for everyone that died, it'd be fair dont u reckon I would have saved Fred to kill Neville, that's all I can think of nah not Neville, he did helped Harry at the end.. save Fred or Tonks and kill Slughorn Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now